Do anti-barking devices actually work?
Written by
Robert Brown
Reviewed by
Prof. Henry Webster, Ph.D.Results from " anti-barking Devices of various types, such as collars and emitters, vary according to their design and application. I have tried many models of these devices with clients over the years, and there is no question that while some give a temporary reduction in barking, for the best results, there should be a change in the causes And not only in the symptoms of barking in dogs.
Citronella Spray Collars
- Release citrus-scented spray when barking detected
- Best for outdoor use due to scent dispersion
- Require monthly cartridge replacements
- Avoid for scent-sensitive breeds like Beagles
Ultrasonic Emitters
- Emit high-frequency sound humans can't hear
- Effective range typically 15-20 feet maximum
- May disturb other household pets
- Position away from walls to prevent echo interference
Vibration Collars
- Deliver adjustable tactile feedback
- Set intensity based on coat thickness and sensitivity
- Check fit daily to prevent skin irritation
- Combine with reward systems for best results
Integrate equipment with training for real change. Use vibration collars as interruption signals, then immediately reward quiet behavior. I pair collars with 5-minute daily 'quiet command' sessions. This approach deals with both the symptom and the cause.
Look for indications of increased distress, such as increased panting or avoidance behaviors. If these are observed, the protocol should be halted immediately. My rule: if results are not seen within 2 weeks, or if the anxiety increases, the methods should be changed. Devices must never be a cause of visual distress.
Professional instruction aids in choosing the right tool. The trainers that I work with are certified, and they will evaluate your dog's temperament and specific triggers. I always suggest consultation before making costly equipment purchases. The best device for your dog depends on the pitch of their bark, the anxiety level, and the living situation.
Read the full article: Effective Dog Barking Solutions for Peace
