How do I select the right filter for my tank?

Written by
Susan Taylor
Reviewed by
Prof. David Walsh, Ph.D.Choosing the right aquarium filter guarantees your fish will live in a healthy, well-maintained environment. These important decisions are the result of many interacting and interrelated factors. For example, your fish type, tank size, and maintenance habits will play a part in determining the best kind of filter for your setup. We will attempt to explore these factors to alleviate some of the difficulties in making informed choices.
Tank Size
- Filters have specific gallon capacity ratings
- Sponge filters suit tanks under 20 gallons
- Canister filters handle 50+ gallon setups
- Never exceed manufacturer size recommendations
Fish Species
- Bettas need low-flow filters
- Cichlids tolerate strong currents
- Shrimp require gentle sponge filters
- Consider natural habitat flow conditions
Maintenance
- HOB filters need monthly cartridge changes
- Canister filters require quarterly cleaning
- Sponge filters need weekly squeezing
- Match effort to your schedule
Evaluate carefully your biological load. Large producers of waste (as goldfish) require a stronger filter. Tank size must also be taken into consideration. Long and shallow tanks give flow a better chance to be distributed throughout than those that are tall and narrow. Consider the measurement of the space available for internal filters. Internal filters save space but reduce the available swimming area.
The flow rate remains critical for the health of fish. Use this equation: tank gallons x turnover rate = required GPH. Most tanks like to have their water turned over 4-5 times an hour. But adjust for species, for example, bettas prefer 2-3 times, while cichlids can handle 6-8 times. Always include surface agitation to oxygenate the water.
Match maintenance with your schedule. Busy people like sponge filters that require little attention. Hobbyists can handle complex canister systems. Remember the type of media for filters: biological lasts the longest, chemical needs replacement much of the time. Weigh these factors carefully for a successful outcome.
Read the full article: Aquarium Filter Types: Your Essential Guide