Why choose stainless steel over plastic identification tags?

Published: October 18, 2025
Updated: October 18, 2025

Identification tags made of stainless steel offer superior protection for active pets compared with plastic. The metal can withstand exposure to water and chewing without corroding. The engraving is easy to read for years, unlike the fading of plastic tags. Lifetime warranties offer protection against defects, whereas the protection period for plastic is typically limited.

Weather Resistance

  • Saltwater immunity prevents beach corrosion
  • Freeze-proof performance down to -20°C
  • UV protection maintains engraving clarity
  • Mud-resistant surface cleans easily

Structural Integrity

  • Chew-resistant surface withstands biting
  • Impact-proof against drops onto hard surfaces
  • No warping in extreme temperatures
  • Scratch-resistant engraving protection

The durability of engraving makes steel tags reliable. After two years, my client's tag had become an unreadable piece of plastic, while the steel tag continued to be readable. Plastic shows white stress marks from minor impacts. Steel retains its professional look through years of adventure. Deep engraving will not fade like plastic surface printing.

Material Comparison
FeatureSaltwater resistanceStainless Steel
Excellent
Plastic
Poor
FeatureChewing durabilityStainless Steel
High resistance
Plastic
Low resistance
FeatureEngraving lifespanStainless Steel
5+ years
Plastic
1-2 years
FeatureFreeze toleranceStainless Steel
-20°C
Plastic
Brittle at 0°C
FeatureWarranty coverageStainless Steel
Lifetime
Plastic
1-2 years
Based on accelerated aging tests

Lifetime warranties are worth it. Stainless steel tags carry protection for fading and breakage. Plastic offers only a 1-2 year limited warranty. When my retriever's plastic tag broke after 18 months, the cost of replacement really added up. Steel's durability justifies the original expense for an active pet.

For swimmers and outdoor adventurers, the answer is a resounding no to having plastic. Ocean salt speeds plastic deterioration. Cold freezes and causes brittleness and cracking of plastic. After beach excursions, plastic remains damaged by permanent cloudiness from sand abrasion. Steel maintains integrity in all weather conditions. Use materials that are appropriate for your pet's lifestyle.

Read the full article: Pet Identification Tags: Essential Guide

Continue reading